The Judicial Committee of the Privy Council in London has overturned Trinidad and Tobago’s law criminalising sex between men, nullifying a statute that had stood for more than a century.
The Privy Council, which remains the highest court of appeal for several former British colonies, said it agreed with an earlier lower-court ruling that had struck the law down, CNN reported. The law had carried prison terms of up to five years for “buggery” and two years for “gross indecency” — terms CNN notes are largely obsolete and considered offensive in contemporary legal systems.
Ruling the law unconstitutional, Privy Council judge Philip Sales said: “Those laws cannot be regarded as reasonably justifiable in a society that has a proper respect for the rights and freedoms of the individual.” He added that “laws which seek to criminalize such activities cannot be justified.”
An eight-year case
The challenge was brought by Jason Jones, an LGBTQ+ rights activist born in Trinidad who lives in the UK. He won in the High Court of Trinidad and Tobago in 2018, but the islands’ Court of Appeal overturned that result in 2025, sending him to the Privy Council for a final appeal.
Hiru News adds that the provision dates from 1925 under British rule and was amended in 1986 to stiffen the penalties — and that Jones’s lawyers argued the 1986 version fell outside the colonial savings clauses that shield inherited laws from constitutional challenge.
Speaking to CNN before the ruling, Jones said his case was “not just about decriminalizing (gay sexual acts in) countries in the Commonwealth that carry these British colonial-era laws. It’s about making people aware (of) how homophobia is being weaponized to take away our democratic rights.”
How far it reaches
At least four other former British colonies in the Caribbean — Jamaica, Guyana, Grenada and Saint Vincent and the Grenadines — still criminalise sexual activity between men, according to the UK charity Human Dignity Trust cited by CNN. Importantly, CNN notes that not all of them fall within the Privy Council’s appellate jurisdiction, so the judgment does not automatically carry across.
Human Dignity Trust chief executive Téa Braun called the decision “not only a victory for LGBT+ people in Trinidad and Tobago but another powerful affirmation” against laws criminalising private, consensual conduct.
England and Wales decriminalised gay male sex in the 1960s — the same decade Trinidad and Tobago gained independence — leaving the former colony to return to a British court to undo a British-authored law.