The Court of Appeal has decided to hear the contempt of court case against six people — including MP Dilith Jayaweera and former ministers Wimal Weerawansa and Udaya Gammanpila — throughout the day on Wednesday, Hiru News reported.
The case was filed before the Court of Appeal on a recommendation made by the Colombo Fort Magistrate.
The bench and the charges
The matter is being heard before a three-judge bench comprising the President of the Court of Appeal, Justice Rohantha Abeysuriya, with Justice Chamath Morais and Justice Adithya Patabendige.
The complaint names six: Wimal Weerawansa, Udaya Gammanpila, Dilith Jayaweera, Sugeeshwara Bandara, Asanka Navaratne and Mahinda Pathirana.
Two sets of statements are at issue, according to the filing. The first concerns remarks made in protest at the arrest of Suresh Sallay, the former Director of the State Intelligence Service. The second concerns comments on the Easter Sunday attack case said to have been made in a manner that amounted to contempt of court.
How the case reached this point
This desk has tracked the proceedings since mid-year. The Criminal Investigation Department opened a contempt probe against the six over their statements on the Easter case in June, a step the Free Lawyers’ collective criticised as an attack on free speech the following day.
In August the Fort Magistrate’s Court found that the six had committed contempt and referred the matter to the Court of Appeal for appropriate proceedings to be instituted. Dilith Jayaweera challenged that referral by writ; the Court of Appeal heard his petition in September and dismissed it on 30 September.
The three-judge bench was named in September, and proceedings were subsequently fixed for 15 October. Wednesday’s allocation of a full hearing day is the first substantive step this desk has recorded since that date.
Update: the hearing ran into a second day, with the Attorney General to follow
The case was called again on Thursday morning, and the Attorney General’s submissions were fixed for Friday. The full day allocated to Wednesday did not conclude the matter, Hiru News reported.
President’s Counsel Anura Meddegoda, appearing for respondent Wimal Weerawansa, made submissions when the case was taken up on Thursday. The court decided to postpone both the remainder of his submissions and the Attorney General’s submissions to Friday. The same three-judge bench — Justice Rohantha Abeysuriya, Justice Chamath Morais and Justice Adithya Patabendige — continues to hear the matter.
That answers two of the questions left open below. Counsel is now on the record for at least one respondent, and the hearing has not concluded within the single day set aside for it. The order of proceedings is clear: the respondents are being heard first, with the Attorney General replying.
Still unanswered: what happened on 15 October, whether all six respondents appeared or were represented on either day, who appears for the remaining five, and what penalties the court may impose. Hiru’s own headline describes the respondents as “Wimal, Dilith, Udaya and 6 others,” which would make nine; the complaint names six in total, as set out above. The headline is a slip, not a new set of respondents.
Update, 13 November: the Attorney General tells the court the six face separate cases
The Attorney General’s submissions were made on Friday, as scheduled. Deputy Solicitor General Janaka Bandara appeared before the Court of Appeal and told it that although the Colombo Fort Magistrate referred the matter as a single complaint against the six, there are separate facts against each of them, Hiru News reported at 1.31 p.m.
The same three-judge bench, headed by President of the Court of Appeal Justice Rohantha Abeysuriya, heard the submissions.
The state splits the respondents into two groups
This is the first time the conduct alleged against each respondent has been distinguished publicly, and the division matters.
According to the Deputy Solicitor General:
- Dilith Jayaweera and Mahinda Pathirana are said to have commented directly on the judiciary.
- Wimal Weerawansa, Udaya Gammanpila and Asanka Navaratne are said to have made statements concerning the Criminal Investigation Department and Shani Abeysekara, the former CID director.
That accounts for five of the six respondents. Sugeeshwara Bandara, named in the complaint as set out above, does not appear in Hiru’s account of the submissions. The filing does not say whether the case against him was addressed separately, withdrawn, or simply left out of the report. This desk is not assuming any of those.
How this reframes the charges
The characterisation differs from the one recorded earlier in this article. The complaint was previously described as concerning two sets of statements — remarks in protest at the arrest of Suresh Sallay, and comments on the Easter Sunday attack case.
Friday’s submissions describe the conduct differently: direct comment on the judiciary for two respondents, and comment on the CID and Shani Abeysekara for three. The two framings are not necessarily in conflict — Shani Abeysekara and the CID are central to the Easter Sunday investigation, and the Sallay proceedings are the ones before the Fort Magistrate — but they are not the same description, and no filing reconciles them. Readers should treat Friday’s account as the state’s own framing of its case rather than a restatement of the original complaint.
The practical significance of “separate facts against each” is that the Attorney General is resisting treating the six as a single joint contempt. If the court accepts it, each respondent’s conduct would be assessed on its own footing — which bears directly on Mahinda Pathirana, who has already offered an unconditional apology through President’s Counsel V.K. Choksy, and who on this account falls in the group said to have commented on the judiciary directly.
Still open after this update
The filing does not say whether the hearing concluded on Friday, whether judgment was reserved, or whether a further date was fixed. It does not quote the statements said to constitute contempt, record any response from counsel for the respondents, or indicate what penalties are being sought. It gives no position on Sugeeshwara Bandara. The question of what happened on 15 October remains unanswered.
On a name: Hiru renders the respondents as මහින්ද පතිරණ and අසංක නවරත්න; this desk uses the spellings Mahinda Pathirana and Asanka Navaratne already established in this thread.
Not reported
The filing does not say what happened on 15 October or whether the case was heard on that date, nor whether all six respondents appeared on Wednesday or were represented. It gives no indication of what penalties the Court of Appeal may impose, does not name counsel for either side, and does not say whether the hearing is expected to conclude on Wednesday or continue to a further date. It does not quote the statements said to constitute contempt, or set out the respondents’ defence.
On sourcing and on a name: this report rests on a single fresh verified source, Hiru News. Searches of the Daily Mirror, NewsFirst, Island, Daily News, Daily FT and EconomyNext for Wednesday’s hearing returned the August and October filings in this same thread rather than a same-day report. Hiru’s Sinhala filing renders the second judge’s name as “චමත්ක මොරායස්”; this desk has used the spelling Chamath Morais carried by NewsFirst, the Daily Mirror and the Daily News in their earlier English-language coverage of this bench.